"Variablen","Beschreibung","Details","Code","",""
"Bibliographie","","","","",""
"Nummer","Artikelnummer","","","",""
"Datenquelle","Quelle des Artikels","Gibt an wo das Paper gefunden wurde. Diese Daten stammen von SCOPUS, Web of Science oder Google Scholar. Ein Artikel kann entweder aus einer Datenquelle oder aus mehreren stammen. ","","",""
"Suchbegriff","Variation(en) der Suchbegriffe","","","",""
"Titel","Titel der Publikation","","","",""
"Autor*in(nen)","Autor*in(nen) der Publikation","","","",""
"Jahr","Jahr der Publikation","","","",""
"Zeitschrift","Veröffentlichende Zeitschrift","","","",""
"Band","","","","",""
"Ausgabe","","","","",""
"DOI","Digital Object Identifier","","","",""
"Zitation","Diese Zahl gibt an wie oft die Publikation insgesamt zitiert wurde","Diese Werte werden aus der Quellendatenbank abgerufen. ","","",""
"Folgende Metadaten werden nur in der Analyse verwendet","","","","",""
"Geographie","","","","",""
"Unspezifisch","In diesem Artikel geht es nicht um eine bestimmte Region, sondern um jede Region.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Europe","In diesem Artikel geht es entweder um eine bestimmte Region in Europa oder um Europa im Allgemeinen.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Asia","In diesem Artikel geht es entweder um eine bestimmte Region in Asien oder um Asien im Allgemeinen.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Africa","In diesem Artikel geht es entweder um eine bestimmte Region in Afrika oder um Afrika im Allgemeinen.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Latin America","In diesem Artikel geht es entweder um eine bestimmte Region in Lateinamerika oder um Lateinamerika im Allgemeinen.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"North America","In diesem Artikel geht es entweder um eine bestimmte Region in Nordamerika oder um Nordamerika im Allgemeinen.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Australia/ New Zealand","In diesem Artikel geht es entweder um eine bestimmte Region in Australien oder Australien/Neuseeland im Allgemeinen.","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","","   "
"Partizipationsansatz","","","","",""
"Thematischer Fokus","Thematischer Fokus basierend auf Autorenschlüsselwörtern und eigener Interpretation","sustainable energy development (E )  sustainable land use (LU), mobility (M), biodiversity (B), water management (W) and urban planning (UP).","E; LU; M; B; W; UP","",""
"Forschungsansatz","Thematischer Fokus basierend auf Autorenschlüsselwörtern und eigener Interpretation","transdisciplinary approach (TD), natural resource management (NRM), transition management, TM","TD; NRM; TM","",""
"ID","Kurz-ID, um die Studien zu unterscheiden","Coding consists of country the study was conducted, year of the study and research approach","","",""
"Main criteria to distinguish four approaches to participation","","","","",""
"F1P","Vom Forschungsteam initiiert, um die beste Lösung für ein bestehendes (Nachhaltigkeits-)problem zu finden.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen funktionalen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F1R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F2P","Nur diejenigen mit Expert*innenwissen werden beteiligt: themenspezifische Stakeholder- oder Expert*innenanalyse.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen funktionalen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F2R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F3P","Die Teilnehmenden tragen zur Entscheidungs-findung bei, die endgültige Entscheidungsmacht verbleibt bei den Forschenden.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen funktionalen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F3R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F4P","Wissensintegration (im technokratischen Sinne)","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen funktionalen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"F4R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C1P","Vom Forschungsteam initiiert, um Präferenzen und Interessen abzufragen und Alternativen und Argumente zu verhandeln.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen kompetitiven Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C1R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C2P","Alle Teilnehmenden, die ein Interesse am Thema haben, können teilnehmen oder sind zufällig ausgewählt.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen kompetitiven Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C2R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C3P","Die Präferenzen werden durch Auswahl artikuliert, Entscheidungen durch Abstimmung getroffen.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen kompetitiven Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C3R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C4P","Der Fokus liegt nicht auf der Wissensintegration, das überzeugendste oder dominanteste Argument gewinnt.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen kompetitiven Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"C4R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D1P","Vom Forschungsteam oder einem deliberativen Forum initiiert, um durch einen fairen Diskurs zum Konsens zu gelangen.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen deliberativen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D1R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D2P","Alle Perspektiven und Argumente sollen berücksichtigt werden, auch Minderheitsmeinungen. ","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen deliberativen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D2R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D3P","Austausch von Argumenten. Am Ende des Diskussionsprozesses soll ein Konsens gefunden werden, nach Abwägung aller rationalen Argumente.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen deliberativen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D4R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D4P","Durch die Reflexion gesellschaftlicher Werte und vorgebrachter Argumente wird Wissen geschaffen, um bessere d. h. rationalere Entscheidungen zu treffen.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen deliberativen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"D4R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E1P","Vom Forschungsteam initiiert, soll jedoch größtenteils autonom oder selbstverwaltend fortgeführt werden.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen emanzipatorischen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E1R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E2P","Ziel ist es, zusätzlich Teilnehmende zu erreichen, die sonst aufgrund ihrer Ressourcen (Zeit, Bildung, Status) ausgeschlossen werden (ggf. Einbezug von Mediator*innen).","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen emanzipatorischen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E2R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E3P","Die Teilnehmenden werden durch den Prozess und das vermittelte Wissen ermächtigt. Teilnehmende treffen die Entscheidungen selbst.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen emanzipatorischen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E3R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E4P","Ziel ist ein Wissens- und Kompetenzzuwachs von zuvor ausgeschlossenen Teilnehmenden. Diese werden durch das Wissen ermächtigt.","GEPLANT: Dies ist ein Kriterium, anhand dessen ein Prozessdesign für einen partizipativen Prozess identifiziert wird, das einen emanzipatorischen Ansatz für Partizipation widerspiegelt","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"E4R","","ERGEBNIS IMPLEMENTIERTER ANSATZ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Funktionale Elemente","Zusammenfassung","Zeigt die Elemente eines funktionalen Ansatzes an, das ein Projekt praktiziert hat. ","0,25/0,5/0,75/1","",""
"Kompetitive Elemente","Zusammenfassung","Zeigt die Elemente eines kompetitiven Ansatzes an, das ein Projekt praktiziert hat. ","0,25/0,5/0,75/1","",""
"Deliberative Elemente","Zusammenfassung","Zeigt die Elemente eines deliberativen Ansatzes an, das ein Projekt praktiziert hat. ","0,25/0,5/0,75/1","",""
"Emanzipatorische Elemente","Zusammenfassung","Zeigt die Elemente eines emanzipatorischen Ansatzes an, das ein Projekt praktiziert hat. ","0,25/0,5/0,75/1","",""
"SW","Methode: Szenario Workshop","Dieses Projekt hat einen partizipativen Szenarienworkshop durchgeführt.","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"SIA/MCDA","Methode: Sustainability Indicator Assessment","Dieses Projekt hat eine partizipative Nachhaltigkeitsbewertung durchgeführt.","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"I/FC","Methode: Interviews/Fokusgruppen","Dieses Projekt hat Interviews oder Fokusgruppen durchgeführt ","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"Limitationen, die in den Publikationen genannt werden","","","","",""
"L2","Fehlende Diversität der Teilnehmenden
","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L3","Zeitprobleme","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L1","Mangel an Teilnehmenden","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L4","Unklar, ob Teilnehmende ermächtigt wurden","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L7","Fehlende Identifikation mit dem Prozess","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L5","Beeinflussung der Teilnehmenden mit vordefinierten Daten","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L12","Weniger Lerneffekte und Wissensintegration als erwartet","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L6","Ungleiche Machtverhältnisse","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L8","Zurückhaltung/Frustration","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L9","Methodische Probleme","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L10","Unbefriedigende Ergebnisse","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L11","Experten- und persönliche Meinung waren konfliktär","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"L13","Fehlende Kapazität für Ex-post-Evaluation","","1 ""yes"" 0 ""no""","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""
"","","","","",""